European military heavyweights Germany and Poland affirmed Tuesday that they would not be sending troops to Ukraine, after reports that some Western countries may be considering doing so as the war with Russia enters its third year.
Quick Read
- No Troop Deployments by Germany and Poland: Both Germany and Poland have stated they will not send troops to Ukraine, countering speculation that some Western nations might consider such action as the conflict with Russia continues.
- NATO’s Position: The head of NATO affirmed that the alliance has no intentions of deploying combat troops to Ukraine, aligning with statements from other Central European leaders.
- Kremlin’s Warning: The Kremlin warned that any deployment of NATO combat troops to Ukraine would lead to an inevitable conflict between NATO and Russia, emphasizing the seriousness of such a move.
- Macron’s Comments and Scholz’s Clarification: French President Macron suggested that the option of Western ground troops in Ukraine should not be entirely dismissed, but German Chancellor Scholz clarified that participants in a recent Paris conference agreed not to send ground troops or have soldiers from European or NATO states actively participate in the conflict.
- NATO’s Support to Ukraine: NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg highlighted the alliance’s significant non-combat support to Ukraine, including medical supplies and winter equipment, while some NATO members also provide weapons and ammunition on a bilateral basis.
- European Leaders’ Stance: Leaders from Poland, the Czech Republic, and Slovakia have explicitly stated they do not plan to send troops to Ukraine, with discussions focusing on possible bilateral agreements for support rather than NATO-led initiatives.
- Legal and Logistical Considerations: Any decision to deploy troops would require substantial transport and logistics, capabilities possessed by only a few countries. While NATO rules out military action, Stoltenberg emphasized Ukraine’s right to self-defense under international law.
- Bilateral Security Agreements and Support Initiatives: In the backdrop of a conference in Paris, France, Germany, and the U.K. each signed 10-year security agreements with Ukraine. There’s also support for a Czech initiative to procure ammunition for Ukraine outside the EU, and plans for a coalition to deliver medium- and long-range missiles to Ukraine.
- Concerns Over U.S. Support: European nations are apprehensive about potential reductions in U.S. support for Ukraine, especially given the political situation in the U.S. and the possibility of changes in policy direction depending on future presidential leadership.
- Use of Western Weapons: While some countries have restricted their provided weapons to be used only within Ukraine, Stoltenberg mentioned that it’s up to each ally to decide on any limitations, acknowledging Ukraine’s right to target legitimate military objectives outside its borders.
The Associated Press has the story:
Germany and Poland say they’re not sending troops to Ukraine
Newslooks- BRUSSELS (AP) —
European military heavyweights Germany and Poland affirmed Tuesday that they would not be sending troops to Ukraine, after reports that some Western countries may be considering doing so as the war with Russia enters its third year.
The head of NATO also said the U.S.-led military alliance has no plans to send troops to Ukraine, after other central European leaders confirmed that they too would not be providing soldiers.
The Kremlin, meanwhile, warned that a direct conflict between NATO and Russia would be inevitable if the alliance sends combat troops. “In this case, we need to talk not about probability, but about the inevitability (of conflict),” Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov told reporters.
Moscow’s warning came a day after French President Emmanuel Macron said that sending in Western ground troops should not be “ruled out” in the future, after hosting a conference of top officials from more than 20 of Ukraine’s Western backers.
German Chancellor Olaf Scholz appeared to have a different view of what happened in Paris. He said the participants had agreed “that there will be no ground troops, no soldiers on Ukrainian soil who are sent there by European states or NATO states.”
Scholz said there was also consensus “that soldiers operating in our countries also are not participating actively in the war themselves.”
The idea of sending troops has been taboo, particularly as NATO seeks to avoid being dragged into a wider war with nuclear-armed Russia. Nothing prevents NATO members from joining such an undertaking individually or in groups, but the organization itself would only get involved if all 31 members agree.
NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg told The Associated Press that “NATO allies are providing unprecedented support to Ukraine. We have done that since 2014 and stepped up after the full-scale invasion. But there are no plans for NATO combat troops on the ground in Ukraine.”
At a meeting in Prague on Tuesday, Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk said, “Poland does not plan to send its troops to Ukraine.” Prime Minister Petr Fiala of the Czech Republic insisted that his country “certainly doesn’t want to send its soldiers.”
Slovakian Prime Minister Robert Fico has said his government is not planning to propose a deployment, but that some countries were weighing whether to strike bilateral deals to provide troops to help Ukraine fend off the Russian invasion.
Fico did not provide details about which countries or what the troops would do in Ukraine. Macron, too, avoided naming any countries, saying he wanted to maintain “strategic ambiguity” and not tip the West’s hand to Russia.
NATO as an alliance provides Ukraine only non-lethal aid and support like medical supplies, uniforms and winter equipment, but some members send weapons and ammunition of their own accord, bilaterally or in groups.
A decision to send troops and keep them deployed long term would require the kind of transport and logistics capabilities that only countries like the U.S., U.K., France, Germany and possibly Italy, Poland or Spain could muster.
While ruling out NATO military action, Stoltenberg told the AP “that this is a war of aggression by Russia against Ukraine, blatantly violating international law. According to international law, Ukraine of course has the right to self-defense, and we have the right to support them in upholding that right.”
The conference in Paris was held just after France, Germany and the U.K. each signed 10-year bilateral security agreements with Ukraine as its government works to shore up Western support.
European nations are worried the U.S. will reduce its support, as aid for Ukraine is held up in Congress. They also have concerns that former President Donald Trump might return to the White House and change the course of U.S. policy on the continent.
Several European countries, including France, expressed support Monday for an initiative launched by the Czech Republic to buy ammunition shells for Ukraine outside the European Union, participants at the meeting said. Macron said a new coalition will be launched to deliver medium- and long-range missiles.
In an interview last week, Stoltenberg did not oppose the idea of allowing Ukraine to use Western weapons to strike targets in Russia. Some countries have placed restrictions on the use of materiel they provide, asking that it be used only inside Ukraine.
“It’s for each and every ally to decide whether there are some caveats on what they deliver,” Stoltenberg told Radio Free Europe. But, he said, Ukraine’s right to self-defense “includes also striking legitimate military targets, Russian military targets, outside Ukraine.”
___
