Missouri Governor’s Clemency Decision Sparks Outrage

Missouri Governor’s Clemency Decision Sparks Outrage \ Newslooks \ Washington DC \ Mary Sidiqi \ Evening Edition \ Missouri Governor Mike Parson commuted the sentence of Eric DeValkenaere, a former Kansas City officer convicted of involuntary manslaughter in the fatal 2019 shooting of Cameron Lamb, a Black man. The decision released DeValkenaere on parole, sparking sharp criticism from racial justice advocates. Parson’s clemency record now includes over 800 actions but remains divisive as his term ends.

Missouri Governor Commutes Ex-Cop’s Sentence: Quick Looks

• Clemency Granted: Eric DeValkenaere’s six-year sentence was commuted to parole, releasing him Friday.
• Controversial Case: DeValkenaere was convicted in 2021 for the fatal shooting of Cameron Lamb in 2019.
• Racial Justice Criticism: Advocates called the decision a “betrayal of justice” and a signal of systemic racism.
• Legal Background: The judge ruled officers lacked a warrant and escalated the situation unnecessarily.
• Historical Clemency Record: Parson has granted over 800 clemency requests during his term, the most since the 1940s.

Deep Look

Missouri Governor Mike Parson’s decision to commute the sentence of former Kansas City police officer Eric DeValkenaere has reignited debates over racial justice, police accountability, and the scope of executive clemency. DeValkenaere, convicted of involuntary manslaughter in the 2019 shooting death of 26-year-old Cameron Lamb, was released Friday after serving less than two months of a six-year sentence.

The decision, announced just weeks before Parson leaves office, drew outrage from civil rights advocates, who criticized the governor for undermining efforts to address systemic racism in policing. At the same time, DeValkenaere’s supporters hailed the clemency as a necessary correction of what they see as a miscarriage of justice.

A Tragic Shooting and a Controversial Conviction

The case centers on the December 3, 2019, fatal shooting of Cameron Lamb, a Black man, by DeValkenaere, who is white. Lamb was backing his truck into his garage when DeValkenaere, along with Detective Troy Schwalm, entered his property without a warrant.

At trial, DeValkenaere testified that Lamb pointed a gun at Schwalm, prompting him to fire his weapon in defense of his partner. However, prosecutors argued that the officers staged the scene to justify the shooting. Evidence presented during the trial suggested Lamb was unarmed, and the trial judge, Dale Youngs, determined the officers had no legal grounds to be on Lamb’s property.

The 2021 conviction marked a rare instance of a police officer being held accountable for a fatal shooting. Lamb’s name became a rallying cry during racial justice protests in Kansas City, particularly in the wake of George Floyd’s murder in Minneapolis.

Clemency Sparks Outrage

Governor Parson’s commutation of DeValkenaere’s sentence to parole drew sharp criticism from civil rights organizations and Lamb’s family. Gwendolyn Grant, president of the Urban League of Greater Kansas City, condemned the decision as “a flagrant endorsement of systemic racism and a betrayal of justice.”

“By freeing a convicted officer who unlawfully killed Cameron Lamb, a young Black man, the governor has made it crystal clear that Black lives do not matter in the state of Missouri under his leadership,” Grant said.

Jackson County Prosecutor Jean Peters Baker also criticized the clemency, emphasizing that DeValkenaere had been convicted of killing an unarmed man. “He was shown incredible mercy by the governor. No such mercy was shown to the victims,” she stated.

Supporters Praise Clemency Decision

DeValkenaere’s supporters, including the Law Enforcement Legal Defense Fund, argued that his conviction was unjust and his actions were justified under the circumstances.

Jason Johnson, the fund’s president, said they would continue efforts to fully exonerate DeValkenaere. “While we strongly maintain that Eric is completely innocent, even those who do not must recognize that the ends of justice are not served by his incarceration,” Johnson said in a statement.

DeValkenaere’s wife, Sarah, had also been vocal in advocating for clemency, frequently posting appeals for a pardon on social media.

Governor Parson’s Clemency Record

The clemency for DeValkenaere is part of a broader legacy for Governor Parson, a former rural sheriff who has granted over 800 clemency requests during his term, the most by any Missouri governor since the 1940s. Many of these actions involved lower-level offenses, such as drug and theft charges.

However, Parson’s decisions to grant clemency in high-profile cases like DeValkenaere’s and Patty Prewitt’s—a woman convicted of killing her husband in 1984—have drawn mixed reactions. While supporters view Parson’s clemency record as a compassionate use of executive power, critics argue that it perpetuates inequities in the justice system.

Prewitt’s Release

Prewitt, now 75, was released alongside DeValkenaere after serving 40 years for the fatal shooting of her husband, Bill Prewitt. She has long maintained her innocence, claiming a stranger broke into their home and killed her husband. Her case gained attention from advocacy groups and Georgetown University law students, who uncovered potential evidence of prosecutorial misconduct.

Conclusion

The release of Eric DeValkenaere has reignited a national conversation on racial justice, police accountability, and the role of clemency in addressing controversial cases. While Governor Parson’s decision underscores his commitment to addressing clemency petitions, it also highlights deep divisions in how justice is perceived and applied in Missouri. As Parson’s term comes to an end, the debate over his legacy and the broader implications of clemency continues.

More on US News