Poll: Americans Divided on Hegseth for Defense Secretary \ Newslooks \ Washington DC \ Mary Sidiqi \ Evening Edition \ Pete Hegseth’s confirmation hearing for defense secretary highlighted stark divisions. A poll revealed limited public support for his nomination, with concerns over his lack of government experience and controversial past statements. While Republican men largely approve, many Americans remain undecided about Hegseth’s qualifications.
Pete Hegseth Nomination Quick Looks
- Public Opinion: A survey shows only 2 in 10 Americans approve of Hegseth’s nomination, while one-third disapprove.
- Republican Support: GOP men are likelier to back Hegseth, while Republican women and younger Republicans are more uncertain.
- Controversies: Hegseth has faced scrutiny for past comments, allegations of misconduct, and views on women in combat roles.
- Experience Concerns: Many Americans view his lack of government experience negatively, though some Republicans see it as a positive.
- Commitments: Hegseth pledged not to consume alcohol and promised to be a “change agent” at the Pentagon.
Deep Look
Pete Hegseth’s nomination as defense secretary by President-elect Donald Trump has ignited a wave of controversy, highlighting sharp partisan divides and raising questions about his qualifications. His confirmation hearing, held on Tuesday, became a pivotal moment for Hegseth to address critics in the Senate and the broader public. As a relative newcomer to national governance, Hegseth has drawn intense scrutiny over his lack of government experience, past controversial statements, and personal conduct.
Public Opinion: A Divided America
Public sentiment surrounding Hegseth’s nomination paints a mixed picture. According to a pre-hearing survey conducted by the AP-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research, only 20% of Americans approve of his nomination, while a larger share, roughly 33%, disapprove. Strikingly, about one-third of Americans admit they don’t know enough about him to form an opinion.
This lack of familiarity represents both a challenge and an opportunity for Hegseth. While critics have seized on his controversies to frame the narrative, Hegseth’s supporters argue his military background and outsider perspective are strengths that set him apart from traditional Washington insiders.
Military Service and Controversies
Hegseth, 44, is a veteran of the Army National Guard with deployments to Iraq and Afghanistan. His supporters in the Trump administration and among congressional Republicans have praised his firsthand military experience, asserting it equips him to oversee the Pentagon and manage U.S. troops.
However, his candidacy has been overshadowed by controversies. Allegations of past sexual misconduct, excessive drinking, and inflammatory statements about women, minorities, and military leadership have dogged his career. His criticism of “woke generals” and initial opposition to women in combat roles have been particularly contentious.
In response to the backlash, Hegseth attempted to strike a conciliatory tone during his confirmation hearing. He walked back his earlier statements on women in combat, saying, “If we have the right standard and women meet that standard, roger. Let’s go.” Senators Joni Ernst (R-Iowa) and Tammy Duckworth (D-Illinois), both former combat veterans, questioned him pointedly on this issue.
Hegseth also addressed concerns about his personal conduct, pledging to abstain from alcohol if confirmed and emphasizing his commitment to professionalism and leadership.
Partisan Divides in Support
Hegseth’s nomination has revealed stark partisan divides, particularly among Republicans. The AP-NORC poll found that Republican men are more likely to support him, with nearly half approving of his nomination. In contrast, only about one-third of Republican women expressed support, while roughly half of GOP women remain undecided.
Age further influences Republican sentiment. Older Republicans, particularly those over 45, are more likely to back Hegseth, with about half expressing approval. Among younger Republicans under 45, support drops to about 30%, with many still undecided.
The differences extend to gender and generational lines, reflecting broader trends within the GOP. Women and younger voters are often less inclined to back controversial nominees, especially those with a history of divisive statements.
Experience: A Double-Edged Sword
A key point of debate is Hegseth’s lack of traditional government experience. During his hearing, he acknowledged he does not fit the mold of past defense secretaries, but he argued that this could be an asset. “I’m not coming to Washington to maintain the status quo,” he declared, promising to be a “change agent” who challenges entrenched norms.
Despite his assurances, the AP-NORC poll revealed that many Americans view his outsider status negatively. About 50% believe it is a “very” or “somewhat” bad idea for the president to rely on advisers without government backgrounds. Only 25% consider it a “very” or “somewhat” good idea, while another 25% remain neutral.
Republicans, however, are more supportive of Hegseth’s outsider credentials. Approximately 40% of GOP respondents view his lack of government experience positively, compared to just 10% of Democrats and 20% of independents.
What Lies Ahead
Hegseth faces a difficult road to confirmation, navigating a politically charged environment where his qualifications and character are under intense scrutiny. While he has the backing of key Republican leaders, public opinion remains divided, and his controversial past continues to spark debate.
In the coming weeks, Hegseth must work to build trust not only among skeptical senators but also with the American people. His performance during the confirmation hearing provided a glimpse into his approach, blending military credentials with promises of reform and accountability. However, whether this will be enough to overcome opposition remains uncertain.
If confirmed, Hegseth will lead the Pentagon during a critical period of geopolitical challenges and domestic political divides. His ability to navigate these dynamics and build bipartisan confidence will likely define his tenure.
Poll: Americans Poll: Americans
You must Register or Login to post a comment.