LA Wildfires Highlight Major Failures in Emergency Alert System \ Newslooks \ Washington DC \ Mary Sidiqi \ Evening Edition \ The LA wildfires have once again revealed flaws in emergency alert systems, with evacuation orders delayed in some of the hardest-hit areas. Residents of Altadena, where the highest number of fatalities occurred, reported receiving no warnings before flames engulfed their homes. LA County has now ordered an independent review of how alerts were handled for both the Eaton Fire and Palisades Fire. Experts warn that complex alert systems, communication failures, and stretched resources continue to put lives at risk during disasters.
LA Wildfires & Emergency Alert Failures: Quick Looks
- Delayed Evacuation Orders: Some neighborhoods received evacuation alerts hours after homes caught fire, particularly in West Altadena.
- Residents Caught Off Guard: Many victims were unaware of the rapidly spreading flames due to a lack of official notifications.
- County Orders Investigation: LA officials approved an independent review to assess why alerts failed and how to fix the system.
- Firefighters Overwhelmed: First responders struggled with limited resources, radio issues, and grounded air support due to high winds.
- Pattern of Alert Failures: Similar issues occurred in the 2017 Tubbs Fire, 2018 Camp Fire, 2021 Marshall Fire, and 2023 Lahaina Fire.
- Residents Turn to Apps for Help: Many evacuees relied on Watch Duty, a third-party app, for faster, more reliable information than official sources.
Deep Look
Evacuation Warnings Came Too Late for Many Residents
When wildfires erupted in Southern California on January 7, LA’s emergency notification system failed many residents in the most vulnerable areas.
One of the hardest-hit locations was West Altadena, where the majority of confirmed fatalities occurred. Despite reports of burning homes before midnight, no evacuation warnings or alerts were issued to that area until hours later.
Timeline of Alert Failures
Midnight – 3:30 AM: A Crucial Window
An Associated Press review of scanner traffic and emergency response records shows gaps in communication during the most dangerous hours:
- 12:07 AM: LA County officials issued evacuation orders east of Altadena’s North Lake Avenue, but West Altadena received no alerts.
- 12:30 AM – 3:00 AM: Multiple calls flooded 911 reporting homes on fire, but no evacuation orders were sent to those areas.
- 3:30 AM: Officials finally issued broad evacuation orders across 12 Altadena neighborhoods.
By this time, the fire had already consumed multiple homes and taken lives.
Residents Describe Chaos & Lack of Warnings
For many West Altadena residents, the first sign of danger came not from emergency alerts, but from the fire itself.
Susan Lee Streets: “We Almost Went to Sleep in a Burning House”
Susan Lee Streets and her family, who signed up for official alerts via Nixle, received no warning before losing power and cell reception.
“If we had even been informed that houses were burning, we would have known better what was happening.”
They left their home on their own at 10 PM, unaware that the fire was growing dangerously close.
“We almost went to sleep that night with two kids and a dog and two cats in the house.”
At 3:00 AM—five hours later—she finally received an evacuation notice on her phone, but it was too late. Their home and all their belongings were already gone.
“We lost everything, everything,” she said in tears.
Jodi & Jeff Moreno: Relied on Neighborhood Apps Instead of Official Alerts
Jodi and Jeff Moreno first heard about the fire from a neighborhood app. Their first official warning came at 2:30 AM, when authorities yelled through a bullhorn to evacuate.
“We were navigating it on our own. Some people were going, some were staying. We had no clear direction.”
There were no official text alerts until after they had already left.
Why Did the Emergency Alert System Fail?
1. Communication Breakdown Between Agencies
Emergency alerts require seamless coordination between firefighters, law enforcement, and government agencies. But during the wildfires, key communication links failed:
- Firefighters on the ground requested evacuations, but orders were not issued in time.
- Air support was grounded due to hurricane-force winds, making it harder for officials to assess the fire’s spread.
- Limited radio connectivity and wind noise hindered real-time communication between agencies.
2. Overlapping Alert Systems Create Confusion
LA County’s emergency alert system is a patchwork of different services, leading to:
- Confusing sign-ups (residents must navigate a list of 57 different alert systems).
- Delays in issuing messages across multiple platforms.
- No clear process for coordinating between city and county alerts.
3. Lack of Urgency in LA’s Disaster Plans
The county’s emergency preparedness plans did not prioritize fixing the alert system:
- A 2024 Hazard Mitigation Plan included assessing gaps in alerts, but only gave it medium priority with a 10-year timeline.
- The 2020 County Hazard Mitigation Plan did not mention emergency alerts at all.
Result: When the fires hit, the broken system cost lives.
Third-Party Apps Became a Lifeline for Many Residents
Frustrated by slow and unclear official warnings, many evacuees turned to Watch Duty, an app that tracks real-time wildfires.
- Nick Russell, VP of Watch Duty, explained that their system consolidates real-time updates from firefighters, emergency radio scanners, and residents.
- Unlike official alerts, Watch Duty provides constant updates and live evacuation maps.
“The ideal system warns people and keeps them informed. Official alerts often fail to do both.”
Apps like Watch Duty and Citizen have become essential tools as government alert systems continue to show critical flaws.
LA County Orders Independent Review
After widespread criticism and public outcry, LA County officials approved an external review of the emergency alert system.
Officials declined to answer specific questions about the delays in issuing warnings, but stated:
“We are committed to fully engaging in this review and ensuring our systems work as they should.”
The investigation will assess:
- Why evacuation orders were delayed.
- How communication between agencies broke down.
- What improvements can be made for future disasters.
What’s Next? Improving Emergency Alerts in the Future
Disaster experts say LA County must take immediate action to fix the system before the next wildfire season.
Urgent Steps That Must Be Taken:
- Streamline emergency alerts into one unified system.
- Ensure all residents receive clear, real-time updates.
- Fix communication gaps between agencies to speed up evacuation orders.
- Invest in better warning technology, including AI-driven fire tracking.
- Make emergency alerts a top priority, rather than a 10-year project.
Unless major changes happen soon, another wildfire tragedy could unfold the same way.
LA Wildfires Highlight LA Wildfires Highlight
You must Register or Login to post a comment.