Trump’s Bold Gaza Proposal Sparks Debate Among Faith Leaders

Trump’s Bold Gaza Proposal Sparks Debate Among Faith Leaders \ Newslooks \ Washington DC \ Mary Sidiqi \ Evening Edition \ Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu met with evangelical Christian leaders in the U.S. before his high-stakes meeting with President Donald Trump. The meeting highlighted the deep ties between Christian Zionists and Israel, a relationship that holds significant political influence as Trump pushes for a controversial vision for Gaza’s future. Trump’s proposal to relocate Palestinians and develop Gaza into a tourist hub has drawn strong reactions from Muslim and Jewish leaders, with some praising his bold new vision and others condemning it as a colonialist overreach.

Quick Looks

• Netanyahu Meets Evangelicals First: Before speaking with Trump and U.S. officials, Netanyahu met with top evangelical leaders, highlighting their strong pro-Israel influence.
• Christian Zionist Support: Evangelicals, including John Hagee and Mike Huckabee, reaffirmed their commitment to Israel’s sovereignty and territorial expansion.
• Trump’s Bold Gaza Proposal: Trump suggested the U.S. could take control of Gaza and relocate Palestinians elsewhere, calling it “the Riviera of the Middle East.”
• Jared Kushner’s Vision: Kushner described Gaza’s waterfront property as “very valuable,” suggesting a real estate-driven redevelopment.
• Muslim Leaders Condemn Proposal: CAIR’s Nihad Awad rejected Trump’s plan, calling it “colonialist” and a violation of Palestinian sovereignty.
• Jewish Leaders Divided: Reform Judaism’s Rabbi Rick Jacobs called Trump’s plan unrealistic, while Orthodox leader Rabbi Moshe Hauer said it might be worth discussing.
• Republican Jewish Coalition Praises Trump: The group hailed him as “the most pro-Israel president”, embracing his disruptive approach to Middle East policy.
• West Bank Name Controversy: Senator Tom Cotton and Rep. Claudia Tenney introduced legislation to officially rename the West Bank as ‘Judea and Samaria’ in U.S. documents.
• Biblical Justification for Israel’s Claim: Huckabee and other Christian Zionists argue that God granted Israel eternal rights to the West Bank and Gaza.
• What’s Next? Trump’s proposed relocation of Palestinians could lead to diplomatic backlash, increased instability, or new U.S.-Israel policy shifts.

Deep Look

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu arrived in Washington this week for high-stakes talks with President Donald Trump. But before his meeting at the White House, Netanyahu first sat down with influential evangelical Christian leaders, underscoring the deep alliance between Israel and American Christian Zionists.

The meeting took place Monday at Blair House, just a day before Trump shocked the world by suggesting that the U.S. could take control of Gaza and permanently relocate its Palestinian population. Evangelical leaders—longtime supporters of Israel—were among the first to meet with Netanyahu, reinforcing their strong backing of Israeli policies, including territorial claims over Gaza and the West Bank.

Christian Zionists: A Key Political Force in U.S.-Israel Relations

The group that met with Netanyahu included Pastor John Hagee, founder of Christians United for Israel (CUFI), which boasts 10 million members, as well as former Arkansas Governor Mike Huckabee, Trump’s nominee for U.S. Ambassador to Israel.

“The fact that our meeting took place before Netanyahu met with President Trump and U.S. elected officials speaks volumes about the historic friendship between Israel and Christians in America,” said Pastor Jentezen Franklin, a Georgia megachurch leader and former Trump spiritual adviser.

Christian Zionists believe that Israel’s existence and territorial expansion fulfill biblical prophecy. Many see U.S. support for Israel as a divine obligation, and some believe that the eventual conversion of Jews to Christianity is part of this religious vision.

Netanyahu’s decision to meet with evangelical leaders before engaging with American Jewish leaders signals the increasing political clout of Christian Zionists, particularly as Trump ramps up his second-term foreign policy initiatives.

Trump’s Vision for Gaza: Bold Plan or Colonial Overreach?

At a joint press conference with Netanyahu on Tuesday, Trump made one of his most dramatic foreign policy statements yet—suggesting that the U.S. should relocate Palestinians from Gaza and take control of the land.

“I see Gaza as the ‘Riviera of the Middle East.’ We could make it something magnificent,” Trump said.

Trump’s son-in-law and former adviser, Jared Kushner, echoed this sentiment, calling Gaza’s waterfront property “very valuable”.

“I would move the people out and clean it up,” Kushner had said in an earlier interview.

Reactions from Muslim and Jewish Leaders

Trump’s remarks immediately sparked global backlash, with many calling them a modern colonialist proposal that disregards Palestinian sovereignty and rights.

Muslim Leaders Strongly Condemn Trump’s Proposal

Nihad Awad, executive director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), called Trump’s comments “an absolute non-starter.”

“Gaza belongs to the Palestinian people, not the United States. Trump’s call to displace Palestinians—either temporarily or permanently—is outrageous.”

Salam Al-Marayati, president of the Muslim Public Affairs Council, warned that any forced relocation of Palestinians would fuel resistance and instability.

“This will only escalate violence. It will ignite even stronger anti-American sentiment across the Middle East.”

Jewish Leaders Offer Mixed Reactions

The response from U.S. Jewish leaders has been divided.

Rabbi Rick Jacobs, president of the Union for Reform Judaism, criticized Trump’s plan as counterproductive.

“This moment requires bold thinking, but forcibly removing either population will only perpetuate conflict. A two-state solution must come from direct negotiations, not unilateral declarations.”

However, Rabbi Moshe Hauer of the Orthodox Union suggested Trump’s proposal could merit discussion.

“Past policies have been a disaster. Maybe it’s time to ask, ‘What if this actually works?’”

The Republican Jewish Coalition praised Trump’s disruptive approach, calling him “the most pro-Israel president in U.S. history.”

“Decades of failed policies have brought nothing but conflict. Trump is finally thinking outside the box,” said Sam Markstein, the group’s communications director.

The West Bank Debate: Judea and Samaria vs. Palestine

Trump’s remarks come amid a broader push by Christian Zionists and Republican lawmakers to reshape U.S. policy toward Israeli-occupied territories.

This week, Senator Tom Cotton (R-AR) and Representative Claudia Tenney (R-NY) introduced legislation to require all official U.S. documents to refer to the West Bank as ‘Judea and Samaria’—the biblical names used by Israel’s government.

“The Jewish people’s legal and historic rights to Judea and Samaria go back thousands of years,” Cotton said. “The U.S. should stop using the politically charged term ‘West Bank.’”

The Road Ahead: Trump’s Growing Influence on U.S.-Israel Policy

With Netanyahu rebuilding ties with Trump and evangelical support for Israel at an all-time high, the coming months will likely see more bold U.S. policy shifts regarding Gaza, the West Bank, and the broader Israel-Palestine conflict.

The big questions remain:

• Will Trump’s proposal to relocate Palestinians gain traction, or be rejected outright?
• How will Netanyahu balance support from evangelicals and traditional Jewish allies?
• Could Trump’s disruptive foreign policy lead to peace, or greater instability in the region?

For now, the alliance between Trump, Netanyahu, and Christian Zionists remains a powerful force in shaping U.S.-Israel relations, with global repercussions still unfolding.

More on US News