Pope Francis Changed Church Policies on Death Penalty, Nuclear, Kept it on Abortion/ Newslooks/ WASHINGTON/ J. Mansour/ Morning Edition/ Pope Francis left a complex legacy shaped by bold reforms and traditional stances. He modernized Catholic teaching on issues like the death penalty, nuclear weapons, and LGBTQ+ outreach, while maintaining the Church’s core positions on abortion and celibacy. His approach blended compassion, dialogue, and institutional reform across a global stage.
Pope Francis’ Views and Reforms – Quick Looks
- Abortion: Firmly opposed abortion, but expanded forgiveness and pastoral support.
- Death Penalty: Declared capital punishment “inadmissible” in all cases.
- Nuclear Weapons: Condemned even the possession of nuclear arms.
- LGBTQ+ Issues: Welcomed LGBTQ+ people, approved blessings, but upheld doctrine.
- Environment: Issued landmark encyclicals warning of climate crisis.
- Abuse Crisis: Took historic steps but faced criticism over certain cases.
- Migration: Advocated for refugee rights and denounced global apathy.
- China Deal: Approved bishop nomination agreement to normalize relations.
- Vatican Reform: Overhauled financial systems and promoted lay oversight.
- Women in Church: Broadened female roles, but upheld male priesthood.
- Celibacy: Maintained requirement, despite calls for change.
- COVID Response: Encouraged vaccines, urged solidarity and equity.
- Islam Relations: Deepened interfaith dialogue with Sunni and Shiite leaders.
- Divorce: Opened path for some divorced Catholics to receive Communion.
- Latin Mass: Re-imposed restrictions to preserve unity.
Deep Look: Pope Francis’ Positions on Major Church and Global Issues
VATICAN CITY — Pope Francis, who passed away at age 88, redefined the papacy for the 21st century by challenging entrenched Church norms while reinforcing others. His tenure was marked by bold steps in doctrine, diplomacy, and pastoral care, often walking a tightrope between progressives and traditionalists.
Here’s a comprehensive look at where Francis stood on some of the Catholic Church’s most debated and consequential issues:
Abortion
Francis upheld the Church’s firm opposition to abortion, likening it to hiring a contract killer. However, he shifted the tone toward compassion and reconciliation, allowing ordinary priests (not just bishops) to absolve women who had abortions and urging spiritual accompaniment over condemnation. He opposed efforts by U.S. bishops to deny Communion to politicians like President Joe Biden.
Death Penalty & Nuclear Weapons
Francis altered Church teaching to declare the death penalty “inadmissible” under all circumstances, a major break from past positions that allowed it in rare cases. He also took an unprecedented stance on nuclear weapons, labeling even their possession as immoral, pushing the Church into deeper advocacy for global disarmament.
Sexual Abuse Scandal
After initially mishandling abuse allegations in Chile, Francis reversed course, apologized to victims, and pressed the entire Chilean bishops’ conference to resign. He defrocked former Cardinal Theodore McCarrick, removed the pontifical secrecy surrounding abuse investigations, and set up procedures to hold bishops accountable. Still, critics said his record remained inconsistent, especially in high-profile cases.
Environment
Francis emerged as one of the world’s most outspoken religious leaders on climate change. His 2015 encyclical Laudato Si framed environmental protection as a moral and spiritual imperative, condemning the global economy’s exploitation of natural resources and the poor. A 2023 update criticized the U.S. and warned of an impending climate tipping point.
LGBTQ+ Outreach
From his iconic “Who am I to judge?” statement to meeting with transgender individuals, Francis broke new ground. He permitted same-sex blessings, said gay people are loved by God “as they are,” and emphasized a welcoming church. However, Church doctrine remained unchanged, with homosexual acts still considered “intrinsically disordered.”
Women in the Church
Francis significantly expanded women’s roles within the Vatican and across Church governance. He appointed women to top roles, allowed them to serve as lectors and acolytes, and gave them voting rights in synods. However, he maintained the ban on women’s ordination and ruled out female deacons — for now.
Migration and Refugees
Francis made migrants and refugees a central theme of his pontificate. His first papal trip was to the migrant hub of Lampedusa, and he personally brought Syrian refugees to Rome. He consistently condemned global apathy, saying,
“The Mediterranean cannot be a cemetery,” and criticized U.S. border policies and walls.
COVID-19 and Vaccination
Francis strongly endorsed COVID-19 vaccinations and prioritized access for the poor. He supported the moral acceptability of vaccines developed using fetal cell lines — a move that drew criticism from conservatives but was consistent with Church bioethics. He used the pandemic to urge for global solidarity and economic reform.
Vatican Reform
Tasked with cleaning up Vatican finances, Francis implemented modern auditing practices, cracked down on corruption, and centralized investment strategies under ethical and ecological criteria. He greenlit a sweeping criminal trial involving a controversial London real estate deal, making transparency and justice key pillars of his legacy.
Divorce and Communion
Breaking with tradition, Francis opened a path for divorced and remarried Catholics to receive Communion — under priestly discretion and pastoral guidance. Though not a blanket policy, it represented a shift from rigid doctrine to case-by-case discernment, sparking heated debate among bishops.
Celibacy and Priesthood
Francis preserved priestly celibacy in the Latin Rite, even after Amazon bishops requested an exception to address shortages. He acknowledged celibacy was disciplinary, not doctrinal, but didn’t want to politicize the issue or be the pope to introduce such a change.
Contraception
The pope maintained the Church’s opposition to artificial contraception but allowed nuanced exceptions, including during the Zika virus outbreak. He emphasized “responsible parenthood” and rejected the idea that Catholics should “breed like rabbits,” endorsing Natural Family Planning as the Church’s approved method.
Relations with Islam
Francis made historic strides in Muslim-Christian dialogue, signing a 2019 document on “Human Fraternity” with Egypt’s top Sunni cleric. He became the first pope to visit Iraq and the Arabian Peninsula, and met with Shiite Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani, showcasing his commitment to interfaith peace.
Latin Mass Restrictions
In a move that stunned traditionalists, Francis reversed Benedict XVI’s allowance of the Tridentine Latin Mass, citing increasing division in parishes. He reimposed restrictions, drawing backlash from conservatives who viewed the decision as an attack on traditional liturgy.
Capitalism and Social Justice
Francis was a sharp critic of unregulated capitalism, globalization, and what he called the “economy that kills.” He advocated for universal basic income, dignified labor conditions, and systemic reforms to address inequality. Critics branded him a Marxist; he replied that these were the values of the Gospel.
Relations with China
Francis authorized a controversial deal with China on bishop appointments to unify the state-sanctioned and underground Catholic churches. Critics accused him of capitulating to Beijing, but the Vatican insisted it was the best deal possible to prevent a complete shutdown of religious dialogue.
You must Register or Login to post a comment.