Challenges Facing the Media in a Second Trump Administration

Challenges Facing the Media in a Second Trump Administration \ Newslooks \ Washington DC \ Mary Sidiqi \ Evening Edition \ As Donald Trump prepares for his second presidential term, news organizations brace for a tense relationship with an administration critical of the press. Concerns include lawsuits, threats to anonymous sources, changes to defamation laws, and physical safety for journalists. Trump’s rhetoric and appointments, including figures hostile to media freedoms, signal a challenging environment ahead.

Media Challenges Under Trump’s Second Term: Quick Looks

• Trump’s Stance: Trump has labeled journalists “enemies” and emphasized his intent to “straighten out the press.”
• Key Concerns: Media faces threats like lawsuits, reduced protections, and increased physical dangers.
• Legal Precedents: Supreme Court justices and lawmakers may revisit defamation and public media funding laws.
• Hostile Appointments: Trump’s appointees, including FBI and FCC leaders, have expressed anti-media sentiments.
• Lessons from Hungary: Advocates warn against dismissing the possibility of authoritarian-style media control.

Deep Look

News organizations are entering a second Donald Trump administration on high alert, anticipating a strained and possibly adversarial relationship with the White House. With Trump openly critical of the press, appointing media-hostile figures, and pursuing lawsuits against major outlets, the stage is set for significant challenges to journalistic freedom.

Trump’s Attacks on the Press

During a Monday press conference, Trump criticized the media, calling it “very corrupt” and suggesting the press required reform. “We have to straighten out the press,” he said. These remarks underscore Trump’s long-standing antagonism toward journalists, whom he has previously labeled “enemies of the people.”

Trump’s grievances with the media are well-documented. His second campaign heavily relied on alternative media channels, sidelining traditional outlets while stoking distrust among his supporters.

High-profile legal clashes have also defined his relationship with the press. Over the weekend, ABC settled a defamation lawsuit brought by Trump after anchor George Stephanopoulos incorrectly stated that Trump had been “found liable for rape” in writer E. Jean Carroll’s civil trial. ABC agreed to pay $15 million toward Trump’s presidential library as part of the settlement.

Trump’s legal battles continue to expand. He is reportedly planning to sue the Des Moines Register over a pre-election poll he claims was intentionally misleading. These tactics serve to escalate tension and potentially discourage critical reporting.

A Weakening Media Landscape

As Trump re-enters the presidency, traditional news organizations are financially strained and struggling to maintain public trust. Legacy outlets face competition from independent podcasters and alternative platforms, many of which cater to Trump’s base.

The Trump team understands the political utility of portraying the press as adversarial. During the campaign, for example, routine journalistic inquiries were reframed as attacks. When The New York Times contacted Pete Hegseth’s mother about an email critical of her son, it was characterized as harassment, even though the inquiry allowed the paper to clarify her stance.

Similarly, ProPublica was accused of attempting to smear Hegseth when it fact-checked his claims about West Point admissions. Although ProPublica did not publish the story after confirming Hegseth’s evidence, the narrative of bias had already taken root.

Legal and Physical Threats

Journalists are bracing for increased legal challenges, including potential changes to defamation laws. Trump-appointed justices on the Supreme Court have expressed interest in revisiting New York Times v. Sullivan, a landmark case that protects news organizations from frivolous defamation lawsuits.

Further complicating matters, Sen. John Kennedy recently proposed legislation to eliminate taxpayer funding for public broadcasting, a move that aligns with long-standing Republican goals.

Physical threats to journalists remain a pressing concern. During his campaign, Trump suggested violence against the media in offhand remarks, exacerbating fears among reporters covering rallies and other events. PEN America, a literary and human rights organization, warns that such rhetoric could lead to real-world harm.

Viktorya Vilk, program director for digital safety and free expression at PEN America, emphasized the president’s responsibility to discourage violence against journalists. “It’s important that the president act with responsibility to reduce physical violence against the press rather than encourage it,” she said.

Appointments and Policy Changes

Trump’s appointments to key positions signal further challenges for the media. Kash Patel, Trump’s pick to lead the FBI, has suggested prosecuting journalists for alleged misinformation. Brendan Carr, a vocal critic of media regulation, will lead the Federal Communications Commission (FCC). Meanwhile, Kari Lake, known for her hostility toward journalists, is set to helm Voice of America.

Journalists are also concerned about potential reversals of Justice Department policies that have historically shielded reporters from having their records seized during leak investigations. ProPublica’s Stephen Engelberg has urged journalists to take precautions, advising them to avoid storing sensitive materials in the cloud.

Lessons from Abroad

Advocates for press freedom point to Hungary as a cautionary tale. Under Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, most Hungarian media has been co-opted into government propaganda. Investigative journalist Andras Petho noted that independent journalism has been severely diminished in Hungary but stressed that public demand for unbiased reporting still exists.

“Don’t think it can’t happen in the United States,” Petho warned, while urging U.S. journalists to focus on rigorous reporting rather than positioning themselves as political adversaries.

A Fragile but Vital Role

Despite diminished influence, the media retains significant power in holding governments accountable. Former Washington Post editor Martin Baron emphasized the need for vigilance in the face of likely challenges from Trump’s administration. “I do think he will use every tool in his toolbox,” Baron said.

From lawsuits to physical threats and digital attacks, journalists face a fraught environment in a second Trump term. Yet, as advocates like Petho remind us, the resilience of independent journalism can still play a crucial role in safeguarding democracy.

More on Elections

Challenges Facing Challenges Facing