A Connecticut appeals court on Friday upheld $75,000 in fines against conspiracy theorist Alex Jones for missing a deposition in the lawsuit by Sandy Hook families, which led to a $1.4 billion judgment against Jones for repeatedly calling the 2012 Newtown school shooting a hoax.
Quick Read
- Appeals Court Upholds Fines: A Connecticut appeals court upheld $75,000 in fines against Alex Jones for missing a deposition in the Sandy Hook families’ lawsuit.
- $1.4 Billion Judgment: Jones faces a $1.4 billion judgment against him for falsely calling the 2012 Newtown school shooting a hoax.
- Jones’ Illness Claim: Jones claimed he couldn’t attend the deposition due to illness, which he later described as a sinus infection initially suspected to be a heart issue.
- Court’s Reasoning: The court noted Jones continued broadcasting his Infowars show during the time he claimed to be too ill for the deposition, undermining his excuse.
- Refund of Fines: Jones was refunded the $75,000 in fines after he appeared for a deposition the following month in Connecticut.
- Possible Supreme Court Appeal: Jones’ lawyer, Norm Pattis, indicated a likely appeal to the Connecticut Supreme Court, criticizing the court for overriding medical advice.
- Trial Court’s Decision: The trial court, led by Judge Barbara Bellis, found Jones in contempt and imposed the fine, a decision criticized by Pattis for allegedly disregarding medical confidentiality.
- Response from Sandy Hook Families’ Lawyer: Alinor Sterling, representing the Sandy Hook families, stated that Jones’ criticism of the fines and the judge was baseless, highlighting his broadcasting during the alleged illness.
- Defamation and Emotional Distress Lawsuit: Relatives of Sandy Hook victims sued Jones for defamation and emotional distress for claiming the shooting was staged.
- Jury Awards and Testimonies: A jury awarded the families and an FBI agent $965 million, with an additional $473 million in punitive damages added by the judge. Testimonies detailed years of threats and harassment faced by the victims’ families.
- Other Legal Proceedings: In Texas, Jones was ordered to pay nearly $50 million in a similar case, with a third trial pending. The total payments will be decided by a bankruptcy court judge as Jones and his company, Free Speech Systems, have filed for bankruptcy reorganization.
- Ongoing Appeals: Jones is appealing the judgments in both Connecticut and Texas.
The Associated press has the story:
Court upholds $75K in fines against Alex Jones for missing Sandy Hook case deposition
Newslooks- HARTFORD, Conn. (AP)
A Connecticut appeals court on Friday upheld $75,000 in fines against conspiracy theorist Alex Jones for missing a deposition in the lawsuit by Sandy Hook families, which led to a $1.4 billion judgment against Jones for repeatedly calling the 2012 Newtown school shooting a hoax.
The state Appellate Court said that while Jones claimed an illness and doctor’s recommendations prevented him from attending the questioning in his hometown of Austin, Texas, in March 2022, he continued live broadcasts of his Infowars show at the same time. Jones later appeared for a deposition early the next month in Connecticut and was refunded the $75,000 in fines he paid.
“We agree with the trial court that the undisputed fact that the defendant chose to host a live radio broadcast from his studio … significantly undercuts his claim that he was too ill to attend the deposition,” Judge José Suarez wrote in the 3-0 ruling. “We conclude that the court reasonably inferred … that the defendant’s failure to attend his deposition … was willful.”
Jones has said he could not sit for the questioning because of a medical problem that included vertigo. He said his doctors first thought it was a serious heart issue, but it later turned out to be a sinus infection.
Jones’ lawyer, Norm Pattis, said an appeal of the Appellate Court’s ruling to the Connecticut Supreme Court is likely.
“It’s a sad day when a court decides it can countermand a doctor’s orders. Wow,” Pattis wrote in an email.
Pattis had argued in his appeal brief that trial court Judge Barbara Bellis’ contempt finding against Jones and the fine were “manifestly unjust” because she disregarded sworn statements from Jones’ doctors that he was too ill to attend the deposition.
Pattis said that although the $75,000 in fines were small compared with the $1.4 billion judgment, “the principle and point he seeks to make here is significant.” He also criticized Bellis for faulting Jones for not providing more information on his medical condition, “effectively asserting that when it comes to civil justice, a Court’s need to manage its docket trumps medical confidentiality and advice.”
A lawyer for the Sandy Hook families, Alinor Sterling, said Jones’ criticism of the fines and the judge was baseless.
“Jones flagrantly broke court orders — he claimed he was too sick to attend court proceedings when in fact he was broadcasting his show live — and then he blamed the trial judge for doing her job and imposing consequences,” Sterling said in a statement.
The Appellate Court’s decision came a day after the 11th anniversary of a gunman’s killing of 20 first-graders and six educators at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown.
Relatives of some of the victims sued Jones in Connecticut for defamation and infliction of emotional distress for claiming the school shooting never happened and was staged by “crisis actors” in a plot to increase gun control.
Eight victims’ relatives and an FBI agent testified during a monthlong trial in late 2022 about being threatened and harassed for years by people who deny the shooting happened. Strangers showed up at some of their homes and confronted some of them in public. People hurled abusive comments at them on social media and in emails. Some received death and rape threats.
A jury awarded the families and the FBI agent, who responded to the shooting, $965 million, and Bellis tacked on another $473 million in punitive damages.
In a similar trial in Texas earlier in 2022, Jones was ordered to pay nearly $50 million to the parents of another child killed in the Sandy Hook shooting for calling the massacre a hoax. A third trial is pending in Texas in a similar lawsuit by two other parents.
Jones and his media company, Free Speech Systems, both filed for bankruptcy reorganization, and how much he must pay the Sandy Hook families will be decided by a bankruptcy court judge.
Jones is appealing the Connecticut and Texas judgments.
