DeepSeek vs. ChatGPT: How AI Chatbots Handle Sensitive Questions About China/ Newslooks/ WASHINGTON/ J. Mansour/ Morning Edition/ Chinese tech startup DeepSeek’s AI chatbot, a competitor to OpenAI’s ChatGPT, has quickly gained popularity, topping Apple’s App Store. However, comparisons reveal stark differences between the two chatbots, particularly in handling sensitive topics about China. While ChatGPT provides detailed and balanced answers, DeepSeek often reflects Chinese government narratives or avoids certain questions entirely.
DeepSeek vs. ChatGPT: Quick Looks
- Rapid Success: DeepSeek’s chatbot became the most downloaded free app on Apple’s iPhone store.
- Censorship Concerns: DeepSeek avoids or echoes official Chinese narratives on sensitive topics like Taiwan and Tiananmen Square.
- Contrasting Approaches: ChatGPT provides nuanced, balanced responses, even on politically sensitive subjects.
- U.S.-China Relations: DeepSeek parrots official Chinese rhetoric, while ChatGPT highlights complexities and geopolitical tensions.
- AI’s Role in Geopolitics: The chatbot rivalry underscores differences in AI regulation and freedom of speech between China and the U.S.
DeepSeek vs. ChatGPT: How AI Chatbots Handle Sensitive Questions About China
Deep Look
The release of Chinese tech company DeepSeek’s AI chatbot has sparked comparisons with OpenAI’s ChatGPT, especially on how each handles politically sensitive questions about China. While both are advanced AI models, their responses often reflect the contrasting political and cultural environments in which they were developed.
DeepSeek’s chatbot soared to the top of Apple’s App Store, signaling the growing competition between Chinese and American AI technologies. However, its responses reveal censorship tendencies consistent with Chinese internet regulations, offering users an experience that diverges significantly from ChatGPT’s nuanced and balanced approach.
Sensitive Topics, Different Narratives
Winnie the Pooh in China
- ChatGPT’s Answer: Explained how Winnie the Pooh has become a satirical symbol used to mock President Xi Jinping, noting comparisons to the bear’s appearance and the resulting censorship in China.
- DeepSeek’s Answer: Described the bear as a beloved children’s character symbolizing “joy and friendship.” It abruptly shifted to praising China’s internet governance, saying all online content is managed under laws to ensure “national security and social stability.”
Tiananmen Square, 1989
- ChatGPT’s Answer: Detailed the background of the pro-democracy protests, the military crackdown, and its enduring legacy, labeling it “one of the most significant and tragic events” in modern Chinese history.
- DeepSeek’s Answer: Avoided the topic entirely, responding, “Sorry, that’s beyond my current scope. Let’s talk about something else.”
Is Taiwan Part of China?
- ChatGPT’s Answer: Acknowledged differing perspectives, describing Taiwan as a self-governing democracy while outlining China’s claim that Taiwan is part of its territory.
- DeepSeek’s Answer: Echoed official Chinese rhetoric, stating that “Taiwan has been an integral part of China since ancient times” and emphasizing the “great rejuvenation of the Chinese nation.”
Broader Questions
U.S.-China Relations
- ChatGPT’s Answer: Highlighted the complexity of U.S.-China ties, touching on areas of economic interdependence, geopolitical rivalry, and collaboration on global issues. It mentioned tensions over Taiwan, the South China Sea, and technological competition.
- DeepSeek’s Answer: Closely mirrored language from official Chinese statements, emphasizing “mutual respect” and “win-win cooperation,” suggesting the U.S. should “meet China halfway.”
Regulatory Differences and Censorship
DeepSeek’s responses reflect China’s stringent internet regulations. In 2023, the Chinese government mandated that AI products undergo security reviews and comply with laws promoting socialist core values before being publicly launched. These regulations likely shape the chatbot’s reluctance to address controversial topics.
Conversely, ChatGPT, developed in the U.S., operates with fewer restrictions, allowing it to provide detailed and balanced answers on global political issues. This highlights the ideological and regulatory divide between Chinese and Western AI development.
Implications for AI Rivalry
DeepSeek’s rapid rise signals China’s ambition to compete with U.S.-based AI leaders like OpenAI. However, its censorship tendencies could limit its global appeal. While ChatGPT is widely regarded for its openness and balanced responses, DeepSeek’s alignment with Chinese government narratives may confine its adoption to markets with similar restrictions.
The contrasting approaches also underscore how AI technologies reflect the values and regulatory frameworks of their countries of origin, making them a new frontier in geopolitical competition.
You must Register or Login to post a comment.