House members voted again Thursday to punish one of their own, targeting Democratic Rep. Jamaal Bowman for triggering a fire alarm in a U.S. Capitol office building when the chamber was in session. The Republican censure resolution passed with a few Democratic votes, but most of the party stood by Bowman in opposition of an effort they said lacked credibility and integrity. The prominent progressive now becomes the third Democratic House member to be admonished this year through the censure process, which is a punishment one step below expulsion from the House.
Quick Read
- House Censures Rep. Jamaal Bowman: The House of Representatives voted to censure Democratic Rep. Jamaal Bowman for triggering a fire alarm in the U.S. Capitol office building. The resolution passed with a few Democratic votes, but most Democrats opposed it.
- Bowman’s Defense: Bowman defended himself, stating that the Republican Party’s censure resolution demonstrates their inability to govern effectively.
- Context of the Incident: The censure is related to an incident in September when Bowman pulled a fire alarm, allegedly to disrupt House proceedings during a critical vote to avoid a government shutdown. He pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor count and agreed to pay a $1,000 fine and serve three months of probation.
- Chaos in the House: This censure marks another episode in a chaotic year for the House, which has seen a speaker ousted, a member expelled, and several censures.
- Republican Justification: Republicans, led by Rep. Lisa McClain, claimed Bowman’s actions were intended to stop the House’s business and are thus reprehensible.
- Democrats’ Criticism of Censure Motion: Progressive Democrats criticized the censure effort as frivolous and accused Republicans of weaponizing the censure process for political gain. Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries dismissed the effort’s seriousness and credibility.
- Historical Perspective: This censure is unusual in the context of House history, where such actions were traditionally rare and reserved for serious offenses. Bowman is the third Democrat to be censured this year, following actions against Reps. Rashida Tlaib and Adam Schiff.
- Significance of Censure: Censure is a formal statement of disapproval by the House but carries no practical consequences other than a public reprimand. Censured members are typically required to stand in the well of the House while the censure resolution is read.
The Associated Press has the story:
House votes to censure Dem Rep. Bowman for pulling a fire alarm in a Capitol office building
Newslooks- (AP)
House members voted again Thursday to punish one of their own, targeting Democratic Rep. Jamaal Bowman for triggering a fire alarm in a U.S. Capitol office building when the chamber was in session.
The Republican censure resolution passed with a few Democratic votes, but most of the party stood by Bowman in opposition of an effort they said lacked credibility and integrity. The prominent progressive now becomes the third Democratic House member to be admonished this year through the censure process, which is a punishment one step below expulsion from the House.
“It’s painfully obvious to myself, my colleagues and the American people that the Republican Party is deeply unserious and unable to legislate,” Bowman said Wednesday as he defended himself during floor debate. “Their censure resolution against me today continues to demonstrate their inability to govern and serve the American people.”
The 214-191 vote to censure Bowman caps nearly a year of chaos and retribution in the House of Representatives. Since January, the chamber has seen the removal of a member from a committee assignment, the first ouster of a speaker in history and, just last week, the expulsion of a lawmaker for only the third time since the Civil War.
Rep. Lisa McClain, R-Mich., who introduced the censure resolution, defended it, claiming Bowman pulled the alarm in September to “cause chaos and the stop the House from doing its business” as lawmakers scrambled to pass a bill to fund the government before a shutdown deadline.
“It is reprehensible that a Member of Congress would go to such lengths to prevent House Republicans from bringing forth a vote to keep the government operating and Americans receiving their paychecks,” McClain said in a statement.
Bowman pleaded guilty in October to a misdemeanor count for the incident, which took place in the Cannon House Office Building. He agreed to pay a $1,000 fine and serve three months of probation, after which the false fire alarm charge is expected to be dismissed from his record under an agreement with prosecutors.
The fire alarm prompted a buildingwide evacuation when the House was in session and staffers were working in the building. The building was reopened an hour later after Capitol police determined there was no threat.
Bowman apologized and said that at the time he was trying to get through a door that was usually open but was closed that day because it was the weekend.
Many progressive Democrats, who spoke in his defense, called the Republican effort to censure him “unserious,” and the accused those across the aisle of weaponizing the censure process against Democrats over and over again for political gain.
“Censure me next. That’s how worthless your effort is,” Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries said on the floor late Wednesday. “It has no credibility. No integrity. No legitimacy. Censure me next, and I’ll take that censure and I’ll wear it next week, next month, next year like a badge of honor.”
The vote is the latest example of how the chamber has begun to deploy punishments like censure, long viewed as a punishment of last resort, routinely and often in strikingly partisan ways.
“Under Republican control, this chamber has become a place where trivial issues get debated passionately and important ones not at all,” Rep. Jim McGovern, D-Mass., said during floor debate. “Republicans have focused more on censuring people in this Congress than passing bills that help people we represent or improving this country in any way.”
While the censure of a lawmaker carries no practical effect, it amounts to severe reproach from colleagues, as lawmakers who are censured are usually asked to stand in the well of the House as the censure resolution against them is read aloud.
Bowman is now the 27th person to be censured by the chamber — and the third just this year. Last month, Republicans voted to censure Democratic Rep. Rashida Tlaib of Michigan in an extraordinary rebuke of her rhetoric about the Israel-Hamas war.
In June, Democrat Adam Schiff of California was censured for comments he made several years ago about investigations into then-President Donald Trump’s ties to Russia.
