Arizona Senate debate/ Kari Lake/ Ruben Gallego/ immigration policy/ abortion rights/ U.S. Senate race 2024/ Arizona elections/ Newslooks/ PHOENIX/ J. Mansour/ Morning Edition/ In a heated Arizona Senate debate, Republican Kari Lake blamed Democrat Ruben Gallego for border issues while Gallego accused her of dishonesty. The two candidates clashed on immigration, abortion rights, and each other’s backgrounds, each vying for a slight lead in this critical race.
Arizona Senate Debate Highlights: Quick Looks
- Televised Face-Off: Lake leaned on her media experience, aiming to counter Gallego’s accusations of dishonesty.
- Border and Immigration: Lake pushed Gallego on immigration, calling his record “pro-cartel,” while he noted her rejection of a bipartisan border bill.
- Abortion Rights Divide: Gallego emphasized Lake’s anti-abortion stance, citing Roe’s overturning, while Lake deferred to state legislation.
- Personal Backgrounds: Lake questioned Gallego’s character, highlighting his past divorce, while he underscored his military service and family heritage.
Lake and Gallego Clash on Border, Abortion in Arizona Senate Debate
Deep Look
In a contentious debate that showcased the vast political and ideological divide in Arizona’s 2024 U.S. Senate race, Republican candidate Kari Lake and Democratic candidate Ruben Gallego sparred over immigration, border security, and abortion rights. This debate, the only one scheduled between the two, aired statewide on Wednesday night and underscored the sharp contrasts in their positions.
Lake, a former TV news anchor with a nearly three-decade Arizona broadcast career, emphasized her familiarity with viewers, stating, “Arizona, it’s so good to be back with you.” Her poise and media experience contrasted with Gallego’s occasionally stumbling delivery, although he countered with a detailed military and working-class background.
Gallego, who represents largely Latino neighborhoods in Phoenix and is a U.S. Marine Corps veteran, accused Lake of dishonesty, specifically targeting her claims regarding the 2022 governor’s race, which she insists she won despite credible results showing otherwise. “She will do anything and say anything to gain power, including lying,” Gallego asserted, hoping to solidify voter distrust in Lake’s claims and her unwavering loyalty to former President Donald Trump. Lake has gained national attention for promoting the “stolen election” narrative and has continued her legal battles against Arizona’s 2022 gubernatorial race outcome.
The debate kicked off with a focus on immigration, a central issue for Lake. She criticized Gallego for opposing efforts to expand the border wall, claiming he favored “open borders” and consistently voted against stronger border security measures, which she argued has “empowered the cartels.” Gallego defended his stance, clarifying his support for secure borders but stating that he backs comprehensive strategies involving manpower and technology over physical barriers alone. He accused Lake of favoring a rigid approach that ignores practical solutions, pointing to her opposition to a bipartisan border security proposal supported by the Biden administration but stalled by Trump-aligned Republicans.
The candidates also clashed on deportation policies, with Lake pressing Gallego to endorse deporting all undocumented immigrants. He pushed back, challenging her to oppose deporting “Dreamers,” immigrants brought to the U.S. as children who are now integrated into American society. Neither budged from their positions, underscoring the complexities of Arizona’s border politics.
Abortion, another prominent issue, highlighted their differing views. Gallego portrayed Lake as aligned with restrictive abortion policies, accusing her of celebrating the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade. “Do we want politicians like Kari Lake to be involved in these very, very difficult decisions when they should be left to the woman and the family?” Gallego asked. Lake, countering Gallego’s stance, pledged to respect Arizona voters’ choice on an upcoming ballot measure that will determine the state’s abortion laws. She stated, “We have the choice as Arizonans to decide what our abortion law will be,” distancing herself from endorsing a federal abortion ban.
In addition to policy, the debate took personal turns. Lake referenced Gallego’s 2016 divorce from his ex-wife Kate, now the mayor of Phoenix, claiming that he had “abandoned” her during pregnancy. Gallego, for his part, emphasized his family heritage and upbringing, being raised by a single mother and fighting for the American dream. He frequently cited his military service in Iraq and discussed the hardship of losing his best friend in combat, presenting himself as a public servant deeply committed to veterans and the working class.
This Senate race is pivotal for both parties in their efforts to control the U.S. Senate. The seat currently held by Sen. Kyrsten Sinema, an independent who was elected as a Democrat but later broke with her party, will be decided in 2024, and polls indicate a narrow lead for Gallego. Arizona has transitioned from a Republican stronghold to a swing state over the past decade, and both candidates are keen to appeal to Republican and independent voters open to cross-party votes. Lake’s unrelenting support for Trump and Gallego’s progressive record present stark options for voters who have played a decisive role in recent Democratic gains in Arizona.
Looking ahead, this debate reflects the polarized nature of U.S. politics in battleground states like Arizona, where immigration and reproductive rights remain at the forefront of voter concerns. Both Lake and Gallego aim to appeal to their bases while swaying moderate Republicans and independents who could determine the outcome in this tight race.
