Lawmakers Urge Justin Trudeau to Step Down Ahead of Election \ Newslooks \ Washington DC \ Mary Sidiqi \ Evening Edition \ Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is facing significant internal dissent, with over 20 lawmakers from his Liberal Party urging him not to run for a fourth term. This internal pressure stems from concerns about poor polling numbers and recent electoral defeats, casting doubt on the party’s prospects in the next federal election. Trudeau, however, maintains that the party is “strong and united” and continues to enjoy public support from his Cabinet, despite growing calls for a leadership change.
Liberal MPs Urge Trudeau to Step Down: Growing Internal Pressure and Election Concerns – Quick Looks
- Internal dissent: More than 20 Liberal MPs have signed a letter asking Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to step down before the next election.
- Leadership worries: MPs are increasingly concerned about poor polling numbers and recent electoral losses in traditionally strong Liberal districts.
- Trudeau’s response: After a three-hour meeting with MPs, Trudeau insisted the party remains strong and united, despite growing discontent.
- Public support: Despite internal dissent, several of Trudeau’s Cabinet ministers continue to publicly back his leadership.
- Election uncertainty: The next federal election could occur between now and October 2025, as the Liberal Party operates with a minority government reliant on external support.
Deep Look
On Wednesday, three Liberal MPs—Ken McDonald of Newfoundland, Wayne Long of New Brunswick, and Sean Casey of Prince Edward Island—publicly confirmed they were among those who signed a letter urging Trudeau to resign before the next election. The letter, which has not been made public, is said to reflect growing dissatisfaction within the party as Trudeau’s leadership has come under increasing scrutiny.
Ken McDonald, who announced he will not be running in the next election, spoke candidly about the need for Trudeau to “start listening to the people.” He emphasized that many MPs who plan to seek re-election are deeply concerned about the party’s poor standing in the polls, which currently trail the opposition Conservatives by a wide margin. McDonald’s comments highlight a broader sentiment within the party that Trudeau’s leadership may no longer be resonating with Canadian voters.
The calls for Trudeau to step aside come after recent Liberal defeats in special elections in two traditionally Liberal districts—Toronto and Montreal. These losses have heightened fears among party members that the Liberals could face a devastating defeat in the next general election, especially as economic challenges and the cost of living remain top concerns for Canadians.
Despite the mounting pressure, Trudeau has so far resisted calls to step down. After a three-hour meeting with his party’s lawmakers on Wednesday, Trudeau appeared outwardly optimistic, telling reporters that “the Liberal party is strong and united.” He went on to receive a standing ovation from Liberal MPs in the House of Commons, but this public display of support did little to quell concerns about his leadership. Trudeau’s insistence on maintaining a positive front comes as his party grapples with the harsh reality of declining support and a growing rift between party leadership and its rank-and-file members.
Cabinet ministers have largely stood by Trudeau, with several key figures offering public support. Employment Minister Randy Boissonnault, for example, dismissed the internal dissent as “palace drama” that distracts from the government’s primary focus on helping Canadians. He acknowledged the internal discussions but emphasized that the party needs to stay focused on policy issues that matter to voters. Immigration Minister Marc Miller, a close ally of Trudeau, initially dismissed the anonymous complaints about the prime minister as “garbage” but later softened his tone, acknowledging that the internal dissent had been building for some time.
“This is something that I think has been simmering for a while,” Miller said after the meeting. “What happened in there, although it will remain confidential, is really about Members of Parliament telling the prime minister the truth, whether he likes to hear it or not.”
The internal rebellion underscores the growing anxiety within the Liberal Party as it prepares for the next federal election, which could take place anytime between now and October 2025. The Liberals currently govern as a minority, meaning they rely on support from at least one opposition party to remain in power. This fragile position has only added to the uncertainty surrounding Trudeau’s leadership.
Trudeau has long been a dominant figure in Canadian politics, having first ascended to power in 2015 by reviving the Liberal Party after nearly a decade of Conservative rule. He channeled the political legacy of his father, Pierre Trudeau, one of Canada’s most iconic prime ministers, and won the election by offering a progressive vision of Canadian identity. However, as economic challenges mount and the country grapples with the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic, Trudeau’s leadership has come under fire, particularly regarding issues like the rising cost of living.
The latest Nanos poll shows the Liberals trailing the opposition Conservatives by a significant margin, with the Conservatives garnering 38% of the vote compared to 25% for the Liberals. The poll, which surveyed 1,037 respondents, has a margin of error of plus or minus 3.1 percentage points. These numbers have prompted many within the party to question whether Trudeau is still the right leader to guide the Liberals into the next election.
The pressure on Trudeau has been further compounded by recent comments from opposition leaders. Bloc Québécois leader Yves-François Blanchet has suggested that his party is prepared to collaborate with the Conservatives and the New Democratic Party (NDP) to bring down Trudeau’s government if certain demands, such as increasing pensions for seniors, are not met. This potential alliance could spell trouble for Trudeau’s minority government, as it increases the likelihood of a snap election if confidence in his leadership continues to erode.
For now, Trudeau appears determined to stay the course. Charles Sousa, an MP representing a suburban district in Toronto, described the meeting as a reflective one, noting that while Trudeau listened to the concerns of his MPs, he made it clear that he still believes he is the best choice to lead the party. “Trudeau made it very clear that he feels he’s the right choice, but he appreciates all of what is being said,” Sousa said. “I respect his decision, whatever that may be.”
Ontario MP John McKay also weighed in, describing the meeting as a “candid conversation” between Trudeau and his MPs. McKay emphasized that while the decision ultimately rests with Trudeau, the internal discussions were necessary to address growing concerns about the party’s direction and prospects.
Trudeau’s leadership, once seen as a unifying force within the Liberal Party, is now viewed by many as a potential liability. As McGill University political science professor Daniel Béland noted, “He saved the Liberals back in 2015, but over time, he’s become a huge liability for them.” Béland’s assessment reflects a broader sentiment among political analysts that Trudeau’s leadership may no longer be enough to carry the Liberals to victory in the next election.
Trudeau’s legacy includes several landmark achievements, including the legalization of cannabis, the introduction of a carbon tax to combat climate change, and opening Canada’s borders to increased immigration. However, these accomplishments may not be enough to overcome the mounting dissatisfaction within his party and the broader electorate.
As Trudeau continues to navigate the internal challenges facing his party, the clock is ticking. With the next federal election looming, the prime minister faces the difficult task of restoring confidence in his leadership while addressing the concerns of his MPs and the Canadian public. Whether he can successfully lead the Liberal Party into another election—or whether he will heed the calls to step aside—remains to be seen.
Lawmakers Urge Lawmakers Urge Lawmakers Urge
