The doctors gave Shaimaa Nabahin an impossible choice: lose your left leg or risk death. The 22-year-old had been hospitalized in Gaza for around a week, after her ankle was partially severed in an Israeli airstrike, when doctors told her she was suffering from blood poisoning. Nabahin chose to maximize her chances of survival, and agreed to have her leg amputated 15 centimeters (6 inches) below the knee. The decision upended life for the ambitious university student, as it has for untold others among the more than 54,500 war-wounded who faced similar gut-wrenching choices.
Quick Read
- Difficult Decision for Nabahin: Shaimaa Nabahin, a 22-year-old university student in Gaza, chose to have her left leg amputated below the knee due to blood poisoning following an Israeli airstrike.
- Widespread War Injuries: Nabahin is among over 54,500 war-wounded in Gaza facing similar tough choices, with many undergoing amputations.
- Healthcare Strain: The World Health Organization and Gaza’s Health Ministry report common amputations during the Israel-Hamas war, but exact figures are unavailable. Only nine of Gaza’s 36 hospitals are operational, severely limiting treatment capacity.
- Lack of Vascular Surgeons: The shortage of vascular surgeons in Gaza increases the likelihood of amputations, even in cases where limbs might have been saved with proper care.
- Infection Risks: Severe injuries and infections necessitate immediate amputations to prevent death.
- Israeli-Hamas Conflict Background: The conflict intensified after Hamas militants crossed the border on October 7, leading to Israeli retaliation. Over 20,600 Palestinians, mostly women and children, have been killed.
- Pre-War Health System Condition: Gaza’s health system was already overwhelmed due to conflicts and a blockade by Israel and Egypt since Hamas’ 2007 takeover.
- Prosthetic Challenges: Amputees in Gaza struggle to access prosthetics that would enable a more active life.
- Displacement and Scarce Resources: Around 85% of Gaza’s 2.3 million population are displaced, with limited access to basic necessities.
- Nabahin’s Injury and Treatment: Nabahin’s ankle was injured by debris from a nearby airstrike. She received initial treatment but faced deteriorating conditions due to limited medical resources.
- Post-Operative Challenges: Nabahin, like many others, struggles with acute pain and infection risks in the war-torn environment.
- Changed Lives: Nabahin’s aspirations and the lives of other amputees are drastically altered due to their injuries and the broader conflict.
The Associated Press has the story:
Lose a limb or risk death? Growing numbers among Gaza’s 54,500 of war-wounded face hard decisions
Newslooks- DEIR AL-BALAH, Gaza Strip (AP)
The doctors gave Shaimaa Nabahin an impossible choice: lose your left leg or risk death. The 22-year-old had been hospitalized in Gaza for around a week, after her ankle was partially severed in an Israeli airstrike, when doctors told her she was suffering from blood poisoning. Nabahin chose to maximize her chances of survival, and agreed to have her leg amputated 15 centimeters (6 inches) below the knee.
The decision upended life for the ambitious university student, as it has for untold others among the more than 54,500 war-wounded who faced similar gut-wrenching choices.
“My whole life has changed,” said Nabahin, speaking from her bed at the Al-Aqsa Martyrs Hospital in the central town of Deir al-Balah. “If I want to take a step or go anywhere, I need help.”
The World Health Organization and the Health Ministry in Hamas-run Gaza say amputations have become commonplace during the Israel-Hamas war, now in its 12th week, but could not offer precise figures. At the hospital in Deir al-Balah, dozens of recent amputees are in various stages of treatment and recovery.
Experts believe that in some cases, limbs could have been saved with proper treatment. But after weeks of Israel’s blistering air and ground offensive, only nine out of Gaza’s 36 hospitals are still operational. They are greatly overcrowded, offer limited treatment and lack basic equipment to perform surgeries. Many wounded are unable to reach the remaining hospitals, pinned down by Israeli bombardment and ground combat.
Sean Casey, a WHO official who recently visited several hospitals in Gaza, said the acute lack of vascular surgeons — the first responders to trauma injuries and best positioned to save limbs — is increasing the likelihood of amputations.
But also in many cases, he said, the severe nature of the injuries means some limbs are not salvageable, and need to be removed as soon as possible.
“People may die of the infections that they have because their limbs are infected,” Casey told a news conference last week. “We saw patients who were septic.”
Israel declared war after Hamas militants stormed across the border on Oct. 7, killing some 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and taking more than 240 hostages. Israel has vowed to keep up the fight until Hamas is destroyed and removed from power in Gaza and all the hostages are freed. More than 20,600 Palestinians have been killed in the fighting, about 70% of them women and children, according to Gaza’s Health Ministry, which does not differentiate between civilians and combatants among the dead.
Before the war, Gaza’s health system was overwhelmed after years of conflict and a border blockade enforced by Israel and Egypt in response to the 2007 Hamas takeover of the territory. In 2018 and 2019, thousands were wounded by Israeli army fire in weekly Hamas-led anti-blockade protests, and more than 120 of the wounded had limbs amputated.
Even then, Gaza amputees had a hard time getting prostheses that would help them return to an active life.
Those joining the ranks of amputees now face near-impossible conditions. Some 85% of the population of 2.3 million have been displaced, crowding into tents, schools-turned-shelters or homes of relatives. Water, food and other basic supplies are scarce.
On Nov. 13, when an Israeli airstrike hit the home of Nabahin’s neighbor in Bureij, an urban refugee camp in central Gaza, her ankle and arteries in her leg were partially severed by a clump of cement that blew into her home from the explosion next door. She was the only one of her family who was injured, while a number of her neighbors were killed, she said.
She was quickly taken to nearby Al-Aqsa Martyrs Hospital, where doctors managed to sew up her leg and and stop the bleeding.
But after that, Nabahin said she received minimal treatment or attention from doctors, who were dealing with a growing number of critically wounded people amid dwindled medical supplies. Days later, her leg turned a dark color, she said.
“They discovered that there was … shrapnel that was poisoning my blood,” she said.
The amputation went well, but Nabahin said she remains in acute pain and can’t sleep without sedatives.
Jourdel Francois, an orthopedic surgeon with Doctors Without Borders, says the risk of post-op infections in war-stricken Gaza is high. Francois, who worked at Nasser Hospital in the southern town of Khan Younis in November, said hygiene was poor, mainly because of scarce water and the general chaos in a hospital that’s overwhelmed with patients while hosting thousands of displaced civilians.
He recalled a young girl whose legs had been crushed and urgently needed a double amputation, but she couldn’t be booked into surgery that day because of the high number of other critical injuries. She died later that night, Francois said, likely from sepsis, or blood poisoning by bacteria.
“There are 50 (injured) people arriving every day, you have to make a choice,” he told The Associated Press by phone after leaving Gaza.
At Al-Aqsa Martyrs Hospital, many of the new amputees struggle to get to grips with how the loss of limb has changed their lives. Nawal Jaber, 54, had both legs amputated after she was injured on Nov. 22, when an Israeli bombardment hit her neighbor’s empty house and damaged her house in Bureij. Her grandson was killed, and her husband and son were wounded, she said.
“I wish I could meet the needs of my children, (but) I am unable,” the mother of eight said, with tears streaming down her face.
Before the conflict, Nabahin had started her degree in international relations in Gaza and planned to travel to Germany to continue her studies.
She said her goal now is to get out of Gaza, to “save what is left of me, and to install a prosthetic limb and live my life normally.”
