Mayorkas Reflects on DHS Challenges as Trump Era Looms \ Newslooks \ Washington DC \ Mary Sidiqi \ Evening Edition \ In an exit interview with the Associated Press, Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas defended his tenure, highlighted improvements in border management, and warned against breaking up the DHS. President-elect Donald Trump has tapped South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem to lead the department, with her confirmation hearing set for Wednesday. Mayorkas reflected on migration trends, Trump’s immigration plans, and the department’s evolving threats.
Mayorkas’ Final Reflections on DHS Quick Looks
- Leadership Transition: Mayorkas will hand over DHS to Kristi Noem, Trump’s appointee, after defending his tenure.
- Border Management Trends: Illegal border crossings initially spiked under Biden but fell significantly in 2023.
- Immigration Policy Debate: Mayorkas criticized the political nature of his impeachment and defended his approach to border security and asylum policies.
- Trump’s Immigration Promises: Mayorkas questioned the feasibility of Trump’s mass deportation plans, citing DHS’s existing priorities.
- Defending DHS Structure: He opposed conservative calls to dismantle DHS, emphasizing its unity and complexity in addressing national threats.
- Improving Morale: Mayorkas highlighted workforce improvements like TSA pay raises and mental health support.
- Ongoing Threats: From domestic extremism to cybercrime, Mayorkas advised the next administration to remain vigilant on all fronts.
Deep Look
As Alejandro Mayorkas prepares to leave his post as Homeland Security Secretary, he sat down with the Associated Press to reflect on his time leading the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). His tenure was marked by intense criticism from both sides of the political spectrum, a historic impeachment, and complex challenges in border management, immigration policy, and national security. With President-elect Donald Trump set to return to the White House, South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem has been chosen to lead the agency, which oversees border and airport security, disaster response, cybersecurity, and more. Her confirmation hearing is set for Wednesday.
Mayorkas used the interview to defend his agency’s efforts under President Joe Biden and caution against proposed structural changes to DHS that could significantly alter its role.
Border Management Under Biden’s Administration
Mayorkas’ time as secretary was defined by the challenge of managing significant surges in migration at the U.S.-Mexico border. Under the Biden administration, illegal border crossings spiked early on, drawing fierce criticism from Republicans and concerns from the public about border security. However, Mayorkas highlighted that these numbers fell sharply in 2023 due to the administration’s multipronged strategies.
Republicans have consistently argued that the Biden administration’s policies, including the eventual repeal of Title 42—a pandemic-era policy allowing for the quick expulsion of migrants—exacerbated the crisis. Mayorkas pushed back, explaining that the migration surge was part of a global trend. He noted that displacement worldwide had reached levels not seen since World War II, driven by political instability, economic challenges, and climate change.
“The level of displacement is now greater than it ever has been since World War II,” Mayorkas said, pointing to the hemispheric challenges that have driven migrants toward the U.S. He emphasized the administration’s focus on creating safe mobility offices in other countries and negotiating repatriation agreements with governments to streamline the return of their citizens.
Mayorkas acknowledged the difficulty of balancing humanitarian concerns with border enforcement, describing the administration’s approach as “multipronged” and emphasizing the importance of international cooperation.
Criticism and the Legacy of Impeachment
In early 2024, Mayorkas became the first DHS secretary to be impeached by the House of Representatives, with Republicans accusing him of failing to uphold immigration laws. Mayorkas dismissed the charges as baseless and politically motivated, stating that they overlooked the significant constraints the agency faced, including limited funding and the legal complexities of immigration enforcement.
“We turned to Congress and requested supplemental funding. We didn’t succeed,” Mayorkas said, emphasizing how political gridlock impeded the agency’s ability to implement long-term solutions. He pointed out that DHS had worked to increase resources for expedited removals and streamline border operations, often without adequate support from lawmakers.
Despite facing backlash from Republican lawmakers, Mayorkas also drew criticism from immigration advocates who felt the administration’s policies did not go far enough in protecting asylum seekers. Policies like restricting asylum access during border surges disappointed some progressives, who argued the measures mirrored Trump-era approaches.
Mayorkas strongly defended the administration’s record, highlighting the rebuilding of the refugee program, which had been gutted during Trump’s first term. “I couldn’t disagree more vigorously,” he said, responding to critics. “Do they understand the reality of the number of encounters that we experienced at the border and how unacceptable that is from a border security perspective?”
Trump’s Immigration Plans and DHS Priorities
President-elect Trump has signaled that immigration will remain a key focus of his administration. His campaign rhetoric included promises of mass deportations, a move that Mayorkas questioned. While careful not to directly criticize Trump, Mayorkas noted that DHS already prioritizes the removal of individuals posing national security or public safety threats.
“That is exactly what we have done and what we have focused upon,” Mayorkas said, adding that enforcement headlines can often “instill fear” without clarifying the details.
Mayorkas acknowledged areas where he agreed with Trump’s priorities, such as expanding the H-1B visa program for skilled workers and exploring bipartisan solutions for Dreamers—undocumented immigrants brought to the U.S. as children. However, he expressed concern over the potential for policy shifts that could undermine progress made under the Biden administration.
The Debate Over Dismantling DHS
A significant issue facing DHS under the next administration is whether the department, created in the aftermath of the September 11 attacks, should continue as it exists today. Conservative think tanks, like the Heritage Foundation, have advocated breaking up the department, arguing it is too large and unwieldy to be effective. DHS currently encompasses 22 agencies, including the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), the Transportation Security Administration (TSA), and U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP), making it the third-largest federal department with over 260,000 employees.
Mayorkas strongly opposed such proposals, stating that DHS is more cohesive and effective now than ever before. He argued that the complexity of modern threats, from cyberattacks to climate-driven disasters, necessitates a unified agency capable of addressing interconnected challenges.
“The challenges that the homeland faces have also become more complex, more dynamic, and involve multiple elements of our department,” Mayorkas said. “This department is more fit for purpose now than it ever has been before.”
Boosting Workforce Morale
One of Mayorkas’ less publicized accomplishments was his focus on improving morale within DHS. Historically, the department has ranked near the bottom in federal employee satisfaction surveys. Under Mayorkas’ leadership, initiatives like TSA pay raises, enhanced mental health resources, and efforts to improve workplace conditions helped improve rankings.
“This year we climbed even higher, and that is the product of hard work,” Mayorkas said, reflecting on the progress made during his tenure.
Evolving Threats to National Security
As Mayorkas prepares to hand over leadership to Kristi Noem, he outlined a broad range of threats facing the U.S. These include domestic extremism, adversarial actions by nations like China, Russia, and Iran, extreme weather events, and cybercrime.
Asked which threat the next administration should prioritize, Mayorkas avoided singling out one issue, stating, “I think they need to focus on all of the above.” He emphasized the interconnected nature of these challenges and the importance of maintaining DHS’s current structure to address them effectively.
Mayorkas’ reflections serve as a snapshot of a department navigating politically charged waters while tackling some of the most complex challenges facing the nation. As Kristi Noem prepares to take the helm, she inherits a DHS shaped by Mayorkas’ efforts to balance enforcement with humanity and the growing demands of modern security threats.
Mayorkas Reflects
You must Register or Login to post a comment.