Trump’s Secret Calls with Putin Post-Presidency Spark Concerns \ Newslooks \ Washington DC \ Mary Sidiqi \ Evening Edition \ Bob Woodward’s new book claims that Donald Trump had up to seven private phone calls with Vladimir Putin after leaving the White House. The revelations revive scrutiny over Trump’s controversial relationship with the Russian president, particularly as Trump seeks re-election and continues to criticize U.S. support for Ukraine. Both Trump’s campaign and the Kremlin have denied the claims, while the White House expressed concerns if the calls did indeed take place.
Trump-Putin Calls: Quick Looks
- Book Allegation: Woodward’s War asserts Trump held seven private calls with Putin.
- Trump and Kremlin Denials: Both the Trump campaign and Russian officials deny the claims.
- White House Reaction: Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre expresses “serious concerns” if calls are confirmed.
- Potential Legal Issue: Trump’s private conversations could reignite debate over the Logan Act.
- Public Meetings: Trump has met publicly with world leaders such as Viktor Orban, Benjamin Netanyahu, and Volodymyr Zelenskyy.
- Foreign Policy Contrast: Trump’s recent comments on Russia and Ukraine diverge from current U.S. policies.
Deep Look:
A new book by veteran journalist Bob Woodward, titled War, claims that former President Donald Trump may have engaged in as many as seven private phone conversations with Russian President Vladimir Putin after leaving the White House. The revelations bring renewed focus to Trump’s controversial relationship with Russia and raise concerns about the potential implications of these private interactions, especially as Trump positions himself for another run at the presidency.
The notion that a former U.S. president would maintain contact with foreign leaders is not inherently alarming. Many ex-presidents, including Bill Clinton and George W. Bush, have sustained ties with world leaders after leaving office. However, in Trump’s case, the political dynamics surrounding his relationship with Russia and Putin make this detail from Woodward’s book particularly noteworthy. During Trump’s presidency, a special counsel investigation led by Robert Mueller examined the potential ties between Russia and Trump’s 2016 campaign. Though no criminal conspiracy was established, the investigation confirmed that Russia favored Trump in the election, and Trump’s campaign welcomed Russia’s help. This history, coupled with Trump’s current critique of U.S. policy towards Ukraine, intensifies the scrutiny surrounding his post-presidency communications with Putin.
In his book, Woodward cites an unnamed aide who alleges that Trump and Putin had up to seven private calls after Trump left the White House. This claim has sparked renewed questions about the purpose and nature of these conversations, particularly in light of Trump’s previous defense of Putin and Russia. Trump’s ongoing dialogue with world leaders, including Putin, adds another layer of complexity to his foreign policy stance as he campaigns for re-election.
Despite the uproar, both the Trump campaign and the Kremlin have denied the claims in Woodward’s book. Steven Cheung, a spokesperson for Trump’s campaign, dismissed the book as the product of a “demented” mind and attacked Woodward, a renowned journalist famous for his Watergate reporting, as suffering from “Trump Derangement Syndrome.” At a recent campaign event, Trump also complained that he had endured years of what he called false accusations regarding ties with Russia, referring to the numerous investigations during and after his presidency into possible Russian influence on his campaign.
The Kremlin has similarly denied the allegations. A spokesperson for the Russian government refuted the idea that these calls took place, adding fuel to the controversy surrounding the book’s claims. Nonetheless, the potential for such communications continues to raise concerns, especially given Trump’s long-standing admiration for Putin.
The Biden administration also weighed in on the situation. During a press briefing, White House Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre said the administration would have “serious concerns” if the reported calls were confirmed. While the administration has no specific knowledge of these calls, the prospect of such interactions between Trump and Putin, without any official oversight, presents a clear issue in the realm of U.S. national security.
Trump’s relationship with world leaders has been a significant element of his political persona, both during and after his presidency. Over the past year, Trump has publicly met with several high-profile leaders, including Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, and Polish President Andrzej Duda. More recently, Trump met with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy during the Ukrainian leader’s trip to the United States. These meetings have provided Trump with a platform to contrast his foreign policy approach with that of President Joe Biden. Trump has made it clear that if re-elected, his foreign policy will differ significantly from the Biden administration’s, particularly regarding U.S. support for Ukraine in its war with Russia.
While the meetings with these world leaders have been public, the private nature of Trump’s alleged conversations with Putin stokes speculation about the content and purpose of their dialogue. Robert Orttung, a professor of international affairs at George Washington University, commented that Trump’s affection for Putin has been perplexing from the start. Orttung remarked, “We never really understood why he liked Putin so much, and why he was trying to develop such a close relationship with someone who is clearly an adversary and against everything the United States stands for.”
Trump’s controversial relationship with Putin has been a recurring theme in his political career. In 2018, Trump shocked many when, after a private meeting with Putin in Helsinki, he publicly questioned his own intelligence agencies’ conclusions about Russian interference in the 2016 election. “I have great confidence in my intelligence people, but I will tell you that President Putin was extremely strong and powerful in his denial today,” Trump said at the time. This public alignment with Putin against U.S. intelligence agencies marked a pivotal moment in Trump’s presidency and further deepened suspicion of his ties to Russia.
Since leaving office, Trump has continued to praise Putin in ways that contrast with the Biden administration’s condemnation of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Trump has called Putin “pretty smart” for invading Ukraine and has praised Russia’s historical military record, stating that “they beat Hitler, they beat Napoleon” and emphasizing their strength as a nation of fighters. These statements have drawn sharp criticism from those who support U.S. aid to Ukraine, a key issue in the current geopolitical landscape.
In addition to the alleged phone calls, Woodward’s book claims that Trump secretly sent Putin COVID-19 testing machines at the height of the pandemic, further illustrating the depth of their connection. However, the content of the alleged private calls between Trump and Putin remains unclear, leaving open-ended questions about what was discussed and what Trump might be attempting to achieve through these ongoing interactions.
The potential legal implications of Trump’s private communications with foreign leaders could resurface discussions of the Logan Act. The 1799 statute prohibits private U.S. citizens from negotiating with foreign powers without government authorization. While the law has only been invoked twice in U.S. history, neither case resulted in a conviction, and no charges have been filed under the Logan Act since the 1850s. Daniel Rice, a University of Arkansas law professor, noted that while Trump could be technically liable under the Logan Act, enforcement of the law has been rare, largely due to concerns over politicizing its use.
Trump has previously faced Logan Act scrutiny. In 2016, during the transition period before Trump officially took office, his first national security adviser, Michael Flynn, urged Russia’s ambassador to remain “even-keeled” in response to sanctions imposed by the outgoing Obama administration for election interference. Flynn was later interviewed by the FBI and pleaded guilty to lying about the call, though Trump ultimately pardoned him before leaving office.
Trump himself has called for the Logan Act to be applied to other political figures, including former Secretary of State John Kerry, whom Trump accused of violating the act by speaking to Iranian officials after leaving office. However, Kerry was never charged.
The claims in Woodward’s book have once again drawn public attention to Trump’s controversial ties with Putin and Russia. While some of the more extreme allegations regarding Trump and Russia have fizzled out over time, the former president’s continued affinity for Putin remains a point of intense scrutiny, particularly as he campaigns for a second term in the White House.
Trump’s Secret Calls Trump’s Secret Calls Trump’s Secret Calls
